I'm trying to think of a clue that doesn't give away the answer, although 24 hours is probably quite long enough to be guessing something as straightforward as this. The recap didn't mention my clue so to reiterate: Tuj's question should lead you straight to it. The ambiguity of its 'edibility' is also relevant.
clue: Within the last month, several new games have started in the three MC servers. One of them is very closely connected with this object.
The sharks are circling around the mystery object...
A hint: this type of wristwatch is definitely not valuable, made of a specific metal, or a Rolex Cosmograph Daytona.
Hint: it is not a Rolex.